Last week (April 17) we began our exploration of poetry with an inquiry-oriented warm-up. I presented students two documents:
- An annotated copy of “Alone” by Maya Angelou (annotations by me)
- A FSLL (Feelings, Story, Language, and Lines) that I had completed for “Alone” by Maya Angelou.
Students could work alone or with a partner to record their noticings about the annotation strategies evident on the poem; they also recorded their noticings about the kinds of elements discussed in the FSLL chart. They also got to talk about any overalap they saw between the two. Once students had recorded these noticings, we shared out to the whole class.
The next day, we engaged in a class reading of “Every Day” by Naomi Shihab Nye; this poem is part of a collection in her book A Maze Me: Poems for Girls, a longtime favorite of mine. Students practiced annotation the poem and working on their FSLL charts for the “Every Day”; students also had the opportunity to share their work with a partner.
My two “accelerated” classes also had the opportunity to complete a sticky note lit analysis jigsaw by finding two metaphors and one symbol in the poem. Students had the opportunity to identify the literary element, draw a sketchnote to represent what they saw in their minds when they read those lines, and to write a short explanation of the literary element and how it contributed to the overall message or meaning of the poem.
This past week we engaged in poetry chats to generate conversation and share our thinking about the poem. I did two variations of the poetry chat: one version was set up like a timed station rotation, and the other was structured more like table talk with a large class share.
With the station rotation version, we did timed stations in which students wrote their responses on butcher paper. This pretty much took the entire class period and is a great option when you have the luxury of time. On Day 2, each group was assigned the task of reading over the responses and generating a 3-2-1 reflection to share with the whole class:
Students received a performance assessment grade for their poster presentation and a separate grade for the written poster (content, response to the writing/thinking directions).
A quicker version that is also meaningful is to assign a question prompt to each table group and let them brainstorm their responses on a large sticky note to to then share out to the whole class. Though they don’t get the benefit of the silent “write around” and seeing the thinking of an entire class like the longer version, this version still engages student in teamwork and critical though as well as an opportunity to speak to the entire class. I used the same prompts for both variations of poetry chat, and I also provided supporting notes on any literary elements I felt might be helpful for students. You will note my question prompts say “silent” because originally I had planned for each class to do the silent write-around part first, but as many of you know, time is at a premium right now, and I was not able to do it with three sections due to time constraints.
We are on the eve of state Milestones testing here, but we’ll continue to read poems and analyze them using the FSLL strategies/question prompts to annotate and think about poems. Our next steps will be to take our charts to the next level with 11×17 posters, so stay tuned for a new post on that in May!
Thank you so much for posting this thoughtful lesson. What I love about it is that it’s rigorous, but in it you are meeting the students at their level. It’s a great way for a teacher to see what students are able to notice and extrapolate on their own. I’m wondering if you would mind sharing the Poetry Analytics sheet with me. I tried to replicate it, but much of the print is blurry in the picture. You earned a new follower with this post, and I look forward to reading more about what you are doing!
Hello! I can email you the template this weekend! I’m happy to share!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi! Go to this link and download the question stems: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nI1malznyC0YUJ4Bf6hNzBD9FjqPtwzm/view?usp=sharing . You will need this font for it to format correctly: https://www.dafont.com/bebas-neue.font. Enjoy!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you! My email address is firstname.lastname@example.org. I will use the FSLL chart with my students on Monday, so I’ll let you know how it goes!
Awesome! Let me know if you can’t download it from the link above, and I can email directly to you. Let me know how it goes on Monday!!! So excited for you!
I love this! Can you email me the templates for the stations? email@example.com
Yes! I will try and do that tomorrow from work.
Jessie, I have looked on my school computer and my Google Drive…I cannot seem to find the templates for the stations, but I basically made them scratch with Microsoft Word. If you take a look at the photos of the station prompts, you can get an idea of the prompts and easily recreate them, which is what I’ll be doing in the spring. I am normally an ace with file management, but I am puzzled as to what happened to these. However, it was at the end of the school year when things are hectic, so I could have easily somehow deleted or overwritten the file and lost it.